The Martha Clough Conundrum
After last Friday’s visit to the archives, I’m left with a bit of a conundrum. I found a marriage for one of my 4th Great-Grandparents – John Andrews to Martha Clough – at Willoughby in June 1797. So far so good. To add a little confusion into the mix, there was also another marriage on the same page between an Edward Sylvester and another Martha Clough in May of the same year.
Looking through the baptisms, I can only find one baptism for a Martha Clough of the right age. She was baptized in Feb 1779 and, unusually for registers, has a birth recorded of Dec 1778 to a John & Martha Clough. The only other Martha Clough I can find was baptized in 1756 which would make her at least 41 at marriage. Fine were it not for the fact that she had at least 6 children, with the latest I know of being baptized in 1815 by which time she would be 59!
Attacking things from a different angle, I found a will for a John Clough of 1803 and in it he leaves money to, amongst others, his daughter Martha Sylvester, wife of Edward Sylvester. At this point I’m assuming that I’m stuffed – the Martha I’ve found a baptism for is the same one mentioned in the will.
Looking through the burials for the Andrews family I find that Martha Andrews was buried in 1854, aged 75. This gives her an approximate birth year of – guess what? – 1779. Now where do we find a Martha Clough born around 1779…
Now cogs have started whirring. The John Clough will mentions his other children – Mary, John, Ann & James. I can’t find a record for Mary, John was baptized in 1767, Ann in 1772 and James in 1768. All three are to a John Clough and Mary.
In order to sort this out I need to find the following:
If the Martha that has the baptism record is the one that married Edward Sylvester
- Martha Sylvester’s age at burial should point back to around 1778
- John Clough’s wife, Mary, needs to have died
- John Clough needs to have remarried a Martha
For the Martha Andrews case
- No burial for John Clough’s wife, Mary, before the birth date of Martha
- The marriage between John Clough and Martha lists John Clough’s condition as bachelor, not Widower
- John Clough’s will mentions his wife’s name as Mary
Tomorrow (or technically today looking at the clock) should hopefully give some answers…









